This Week's Feature
Preventing workplace violence
Excerpted from Nebraska Employment Law Letter, written by attorneys at the law firm Erickson & Sederstrom, P.C.
It's universally agreed -- we're an increasingly violent society. The U.S. Department of Justice has reported that during each year of the 1990s, approximately one million violent crimes were committed in the workplace and two million employees were physically attacked, threatened, or harassed at work.
The Workplace Violence Research Institute estimates that each day, 16,400 workers are threatened, 723 employees are attacked, and 43,800 employees are harassed.Even more disturbing is the fact that approximately 600 work-related homicides occur every year.
And estimates indicate that workplace violence costs employers $36 billion each year in lost productivity, loss of life, injuries, employee counseling, legal fees, and court awards.
When an employee is killed or injured because of workplace violence, his employer usually faces a lawsuit. That risk begs the question, how can you reduce the potential for violence at your workplace and limit your liability?
What are the legal risks?
Some of the legal issues you could face following an incident of workplace violence include:
- negligent hiring — failing to properly screen applicants, which results in hiring someone with a history of violence or criminal behavior;
- negligent retention — keeping an employee on the job after becoming aware of his unsuitability;
- negligent supervision — failing to provide the necessary monitoring and oversight to ensure that employees perform their duties properly; and
- inadequate security — not providing security measures that address a potential threat.
Following are two practical steps you can take to address those important concerns.
Step 1: Applicant screening
Your employment application process is the first step in screening people. Design your hiring procedures to identify and eliminate potential problems. Require all potential employees to complete job applications.
Once you receive an application, verify the applicant's educational background, contact his references and previous employers, confirm his previous jobs and job titles, and verify his employment dates.
Why? An applicant with a less-than-appealing employment history may attempt to deceive you by eliminating certain jobs or his reasons for leaving or expanding his dates of employment. A red flag should be raised if you find out someone is willing to lie or misrepresent his qualifications.
You should require every applicant to submit to a mandatory drug test. In addition, perform credit, driver's license, and public-filing checks and most important, criminal background investigations.
Many acts of violence in the workplace and their resulting liability could be prevented if employers simply performed a background check to determine whether an applicant has shown any tendencies toward violence.
All applicants also should have several in-person interviews, regardless of the job they have applied for. Face-to-face meetings during which you can ask open-ended questions provide an additional opportunity to verify the information on someone's application. People who lie often have trouble recalling the details of their fictional history.
Last but not least, you should contact your legal counsel to ensure that you're doing everything necessary to screen applicants appropriately and that you have all the necessary safeguards in place.
Step 2: Prevention program
Avoiding and preventing workplace violence doesn't end with the screening and hiring process. Through periodic training, every employee must be familiarized with and reminded of your company policies, rules, and procedures and the consequences of failing to adhere to them.
At a minimum, your policies and procedures should be contained in an employee handbook, which should be reviewed and updated annually.
One of the most important elements in any prevention program is a zero-tolerance policy for threats, harassment, intimidation, and possession of weapons. A well-drafted employee handbook that spells out your rules and procedures will allow you to take a proactive approach toward reducing inappropriate behavior in the workplace.
You should clearly and unambiguously define what constitutes unacceptable behavior. If drafted correctly, the rules and procedures in your employee handbook often will provide legal support for firing someone.
Once you have disseminated a written zero-tolerance policy to your workforce, designate someone to whom your employees may report apparent violations without fear of reprisal. Consider creating a specific threat-assessment position or department or an anonymous hot line.
Those types of mechanisms will allow management to respond to a reported incident by performing threat assessments and creating crisis response plans. Your failure to take prompt and appropriate remedial measures in response to a threat or an actual act of violence in the workplace may result in later liability.
Bottom line
There are no perfect solutions for addressing workplace violence and the liability that accompanies it. Although it may seem daunting, developing and implementing an effective screening process and prevention program can address not only violence in the workplace but also unnecessary legal concerns.
Copyright © M. Lee Smith Publishers LLC. This article is an excerpt from NEBRASKA EMPLOYMENT LAW LETTER.NEBRASKA EMPLOYMENT LAW LETTER should not be construed as legal advice or legal opinion as to any specific facts or circumstances. The contents are intended for general information purposes only. Anyone needing specific legal advice should consult an attorney. For further information about the content of any article in this newsletter, please contact any of the editors.
This Week on HRhero.com
HR Q&A
Help! It's the birth of a child
From South Carolina Employment Law Letter
Q: An employee who qualifies for Family and Medical Leave Act (FMLA) leave has requested intermittent leave to help his wife care for their newborn child. Is he entitled to take intermittent leave?
Employers Forum
Religious and political expression
What are the laws in regards to religious and political expression at work? We have an employee who has her office full of religious items, such as a Bible, a picture of Jesus on the wall, etc. She is a counselor, so patients come to her office. We are concerned that patients who are not as religious as she is might get offended. What at all can we tell her about this? Can we ask her to take them out of the office, or should we just talk to her about the perception from patients? Is this considered a religious accommodation?
What about political expression? I don't know of an accommodation for this. We have an employee who put "Go BUSH" on her office door. Some employees have been offended.
GLC, KY
Visit Employers Forum to join other discussions or post a question of your own.
How do I join Employers Forum discussions?
HRhero.com Subscribers Area Resources
Get specific ... state-specific, that is. About 75% of HR Hero Line subscribers also subscribe to our state-specific Employment Law Letters. Sign up for your state's Employment Law Letter to get monthly, state-specific updates and access to the HRhero.com Subscribers Area.
HR Employers in the Courtroom
Look before you leap
From Utah Employment Law Letter
In a recent decision, the Tenth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals overturned a district court's dismissal of an employee's discrimination case without trial.
Specifically, the Tenth Circuit found that the employer acted in a legitimate, nondiscriminatory manner in reviewing the social security information of all its employees in an attempt to comply with the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986.
But it may have gone too far in refusing to accept additional documents without investigating the matter further or attempting to verify the authenticity of the employee's proffered documentation.
Read on (Subscribers only)
Tool: HR Answer Engine
Need help with an employment law or specific HR challenge? As an Employment Law Letter subscriber, you have access to a wealth of answers contained in the HRhero.com searchable database.
Log in using your HRhero.com username and password. Need help logging in?
- Under HR Answer Engine in the middle column, click "Search the Subscribers Area."
- Enter words relating to your area of interest in the Search boxes.
- Choose the year and state. (To search for all articles on a topic, select "All" under Year and State.)
- Click "How Many Items" to see how many articles match your search. If you want to limit your seach, you can limit by year or state or additional keywords.
- When you're ready to view the list of articles matching your topic, click "Display Results."
Remember, we're always here to help! If you have any questions, please call 800-274-6774.